data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/75b2a/75b2a818d48905a23f1f2294eb5472e94865356c" alt=""
On approach to the islands the second mate saw a large echo
on the radar but assumed it to be “a rain cloud or an iceberg”, the report
said. At around 5am the chief mate made the same mistake, identifying a large
echo directly ahead as a “heavy storm cloud”. The hazard was in fact
Nightingale Island. The ship, carrying a cargo of soya beans and 1,700 tonnes
of fuel oil, then ran aground, causing serious implications for the islands and
its inhabitants with widespread pollution and its important lobster-farming
industry closing for nearly two years. The vessel would then eventually break
up, and was declared a constructive total loss.
From the investigation, it is clear that an ECDIS on board
would have prevented the devastating grounding in 2011. The ECDIS would have
recognised their mandatory points causing an audible alarm to be sounded when
the danger ahead was seen in the ships path.
With ECDIS on board the crew of 22 could have plotted the
entire route on the chart, with visible clear instructions on where dangers
lay. This disaster and many more could have been avoided.
See the iECDIS teaser video.